Submission and Peer Review

Hello! I have submitted my paper to a journal and it has been 1.5 months since then. How long should I normally wait for the editor’s response, and when should I send a reminder email? Also, if I send a reminder email, what kind of message is appropriate and would not offend the journal editor? Please give me advice.

I conducted a study on the beneficial effects of a Chinese herbal medicine in patients with osteoporosis. The results seem positive but the statistical tests indicate only a weak correlation for the benefits of treatment. I am in a hurry to get this paper published because it will increase my chances for a promotion, which is due soon. I’m worried that the journal will reject my paper if my results are not strong. How should I position my results?

Comments by peer reviewers and journal editors are meant to help authors improve their manuscript. Follow the three golden rules when responding to reviewer comments.

What are the most common mistakes authors make? I will share the views of a committee of journal editors, who are also the compilers of the popular medical style guide, the AMA (Association of Medical Editors) Manual of Style.  

I am about to submit my first manuscript for publication. Since journal editors receive hundreds of manuscripts, I would like to know what aspects they check first? I would like to ensure that my submission makes a good impression.

Most journals require that a cover letter be submitted along with each manuscript submitted for publication. Unfortunately, few authors are aware of the actual impact that a cover letter can have

Dos and don’ts for a great cover letterIn an earlier post, I had described the features of a good cover letter. Here, I’ll pick up where I left off and present a simple checklist of dos and don’ts that you should keep in mind when writing your cover lette

Been looking for answers to your questions on peer review? Here are some!

Addressing peer reviewer comments is a daunting task for even the most experienced authors. Sometimes peer reviewers write long-winded comments, which make it difficult to pinpoint the specific aspects you need to address. Once you receive reviewer comments for your submission, go through them 

Ever wondered what happens to your manuscript once it is submitted to a journal? Does the fate of your paper depend solely on peer review? What are the stages your paper goes through before it is finally accepted or rejected by a journal? To what extent does peer review influence the editorial decision? This SlideShare gives you a detailed account of the journal screening process and tells you what exactly goes on behind the scenes!  For further reading, read Dr. Eddy's expert advice on the...