Skip to main content

Log In/Register

Mega Nav

Publication Success
Get Published
Career Growth
Mental Health
- Mental Health in Academia
- Stories by Researchers
Q&A
Researchers & Their Stories
More
Recent Webinar

29 June 2021

Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts

View Details
- workshop
- Trends

English Editing
Translation Services
PSS Packs

Researcher Q&A

Get all your questions on research writing and publishing answered by researchers and publication experts!

Top Q&A Topics

Manuscript Status

Submission Process

Planning to Write

Research Ethics

Journal Selection Tips

Study Background & Introduction

Statement of the Problem

Authorship in Research

Literature Search

Other Content Types

Infographics & Downloadables

Courses & Handbooks

Webinars & Workshops

Hi ,

What is your academic question today?

Responding to Peer Reviewers

Filter by a different topic

Latest

Q: What does awaiting ED decision after awaiting BM assessment mean ?

Detailed question-Recently, my status of the manuscript has changed from " Awaiting BM assessment " to " Awaiting ED decision ". Does it mean my manuscript has not undergone peer-review…

Asked by First name Last name on March 25, 2024

1 Answer

Thank you for your query.

As detailed on the journal’s author guidelines page, each submission is handled by a Board Member (BM) with oversight from…

Follow this Question

Q: A manuscript status changed from “reviewer reports received, waiting for editor's decision” to “submission passed technical check.” What are the possible reasons?

Asked by Kurtulus Golcuk on March 3, 2024

1 Answer

Most journals run a “technical check” to see if a manuscript is formatted correctly and…

Follow this Question

Q: When asked to clarify a point to the reviewer, should I do so in the paper itself or the response to reviewer?

Detailed question-I got comment from reviewer of one point which he ask to calrify one point in the document (why was a triple marker offered to a 39 year old women? Is it a routine…

Asked by basel nasser on October 13, 2022

1 Answer

Thank you for your query! One of the great strengths of the peer review system is that reviewer comments allow you to present a more well-rounded, comprehensive, and…

Follow this Question

Q: Reviewer says the results of the study are already known - How to respond to that?

Detailed question-I submitted a manuscript to a journal and i got a response that with major revision it can be published. The only comment was that the results of my study are already…

Asked by Sindhu M on July 17, 2022

1 Answer

Dear Author,

The reviewer is likely implying that the findings are not novel and similar studies have been conducted. What you could do is elaborate on how your…

Follow this Question

Q: "In Peer Review" without assigning the AE. What does this mean?

Detailed question-I submitted a paper to IEEE Transactions. For three weeks, the status had been "AE: Not Assigned; ADM: *****; Submitted". Now, the status has changed to "AE: Not…

Asked by Baoshan Hou on June 30, 2022

1 Answer

Dear Author,

Submission statuses on the manuscript submission portals may vary from journal-to-journal. In general, the AE (Associate Editor) is assigned to…

Follow this Question

Q: Status of my journal (Elsevier) has not changed. What should I do?

Detailed question-Hello everyone, I had submitted my paper on 27/12/2021 and the paper status changed to "With Editor" on 5/01/2022. On 20/01/2022, the editor sent back the manuscript…

Asked by Abderrahim Habchi on May 20, 2022

2 Answers

Dear Author,

Thank you for writing to us.

We understand that the status of your manuscript has not changed since the resubmission and the journal has…

Follow this Question

Q: How much time does "assigning for review" take?

Detailed question-I submitted a manuscript to a journal in December of 2021. Within a couple of days the status changed to "assigning for review". After three months I contacted the…

Asked by Jeremi J on April 12, 2022

1 Answer

Dear Author,

Thank you for your question.

I completely understand your distress. It usually takes three to four months for peer review. However, if you're…

Follow this Question

Q: Can I decline the review of an article after agreeing to do it?

Detailed question-I received an invitation to review a paper for a journal. I accepted the invitation. But, after this, I discovered that the paper was very complicated and didn't fall…

Asked by Editage Insights on March 16, 2022

1 Answer

In specific situations, a researcher can choose to decline an invitation to review a paper, such as conflict of interest, lack of time, and lack of expertise or…

Follow this Question

Q: How many peer reviews to expect before publishing how long do they take?

Asked by Editage Insights on November 4, 2021

1 Answer

Thank you for your question. The number of rounds of peer review before a final decision…

Follow this Question

Q: How should I respond to dishonest review?

Detailed question-At the first review, one of the three reviewers commented "Excellent paper offering a clear and important message". However, the judgement at the second review was …

Asked by First name Last name on October 19, 2021

1 Answer

Thank you for your question.

It is plausible that a paper makes a good…

Follow this Question

Pagination

Current page 1
Page 2
Page 3
Page 4
Page 5
Page 6
Page 7
Page 8
Page 9
…
Next page
Last page

Filter by a topic

or

Select all topics

AI & Digital Transformation

Books & Tools

Grammar and Writing

Industry Outlook

Maximizing Impact

Research Integrity

Showcasing Research Impact

Trends in Scholarly Publishing

Mental Health
Mental Health in Academia
Research Culture
Researcher Wellness

Conducting Research
Research Data Management
Data Storage & Management
Data Analysis
Publication Planning
Authorship in Research
Literature Search
Statement of the Problem
Planning to Write
Research Ethics

Manuscript Writing
Academic Writing
Grammar & Language
Style & Format
Plagiarism in Research
Research Paper Structure
Title, Abstract & keywords
Study Background & Introduction
Methods
Results & Discussion
Tables & Figures
References & Acknowledgements
Publication Support Services

Journal Selection
Choosing a Journal
Journal Selection Tips
Understanding the Impact Factor
Presubmission Inquiry
Publication Models
Open Access & Subscription Models
Rapid Publication
Avoiding Predatory Publishers

Journal Submission & Peer Review
Manuscript Submission
Submission Process
Ethical Declarations
Duplicate Submission
Tracking Your Submission
Manuscript Status
Queries to the Editor
Manuscript Withdrawal
Responding to Peer Reviewers
Basics of Peer Review
Responding to Peer Reviewers
Journal Rejection
Reasons for Rejection
Dealing with Rejection
Journal Retraction
Reasons for Retraction
Dealing with Retraction

Career Growth
Securing Research Funding
Funding Sources
Grant Application
Science Communication
Public Engagement
Plain Language Summaries
Video & Graphical Abstracts
Promoting your Research
Professional Development
Project Management
Presentation skills
Collaboration and networking
Career Advancement
Becoming a Peer Reviewer
Career Advice for Researchers

More
News & Trends
Industry Interviews
Industry News
Industry Trends
Trending Research
Peer Review Week 2020
COVID-19
Recommended Reads
Around the web
Our Publication Showcase
Resources for Editors

Help authors by answering these questions

My paper had an "Awaiting Production Checklist" status after acceptance but it disappeared. What does this mean?

My orginal research got 100% similarity on Turnitin. What should I do?

How can I proofread my thesis for journal submission?

View all unanswered Q&As

View Forum Guidelines

About Editage Insights

Editage Insights offers a wealth of free academic research and publishing resources and is a one-stop guide for authors and others involved in scholarly publishing. Our original resources for authors and journals will help you become an expert in academic publishing. Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more.

Become a Member

Contribute as a Guest

Subscribe

Read Editage Insights in your favorite RSS Reader.

Follow us on social platforms

Editage Insights Global Sites

Japanese – エディテージ・インサイト

Simplified Chinese – 意得辑专家视点

Korean - 에디티지 인사이트

Editage

About Editage
Contact Editage
News
Payment Options
Prices for Editing

Publication Support Services

Artwork Preparation
Journal Selection
Journal Submission
Plagiarism Check
Publication Support Packs
Rapid Technical Review
Resubmission Support
Statistical Analysis and Review Services

Quality

Confidentiality
Publication Ethics
Quality Assurance
Testimonials

Editing Services

Advanced Editing
Digital Editing
English Editing Services
Post-Editing Services
Premium Editing
Scientific Editing

Our Expertise

Business and Economics
Life Sciences
Medical Sciences
Physical Sciences
Social Sciences

Full disclosure: Editage Insights is a product of Editage, a Cactus Communications brand that offers expert services and AI tools for all academia on one platform.

English Editing - Editage.com | 英文校正 – Editage.jp | 원어민영문교정 – Editage.co.kr | SCI英文论文发表 – Editage.cn | publicação de artigos – Editage.com.br | 編輯英文 – Editage.com.tw | English Editing Services

Trending Searches

Statement of the problem
COVID-19
Background of study
Scope of the study
Types of qualitative research
Rationale of the study
Concept paper
Literature review
Introduction in research
Under "Editor Evaluation"
Ethics in research

See more

See less

Recent Searches

Review paper
Responding to reviewer comments
Predatory publishers
Scope and delimitations
Open access
Plagiarism in research
Journal selection tips
Editor assigned
Types of articles
"Reject and Resubmit" status
Decision in process
Conflict of interest

See more

See less