Researcher Q&A

Peer Review Week 2020

Filter by a different topic

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

arrow Popular

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

Q: How do I best respond to positive feedback from reviewers?

Detailed question-I have received feedback from peer reviewers on an article submitted, but some of the comments are positive! A number of the comments agree with points made in the…

1 Answer

Hello Annie – Welcome to the forum! And this time, we respond with a bit more seriousness. :-)

Straight away, what a great position to be in! I don’t think…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What are the specific things a journal editor looks for during the review process?

  • Asked on August 29, 2020

1 Answer

Papers to journals are typically screened in two stages. The first, a preliminary check,

is to see whether the paper deserves to be sent for reviewing. This…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Is it a good sign or a bad sign if the review is completed within 23 days?

Detailed question-I submitted my manuscript to a Springer-based journal on July 1. Until August 13, the status was Editor Assigned. From August 14 to September 6, it showed as Under…
  • Asked on September 6, 2020

1 Answer

23 days is neither too long nor too short for the completion of peer review. It could be considered an average amount of time. In fact, given that it’s a Springer…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Is there any higher organization to make a complaint for a malicious peer review?

Detailed question-If I encounter a malicious peer review, can I make a complaint to any higher organization?
  • Asked on July 17, 2020

1 Answer

Your question is so pithy and pointed, we shall also get to the response straight away.

Unfortunately, no, there isn't any higher organization in research…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What is the difference between 'reviewing a study' and 'commenting on a study'?

Detailed question-I have received some comments on a review article from the editor of a journal. He asked me to comment on a few studies that I forgot to review. I would like to ask what…
  • Asked on September 21, 2020

2 Answers

You are on the right track. Comments such as “it was a good study, a bad study, or whatever” is…

Answer
Follow this Question