AI has become an essential part of many research workflows, because of the speed and efficiency it brings to tasks like searching literature, writing code for data analysis, or drafting a research paper.
This guide compares the 4 most popular large language models (LLMs): ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity. It also explains the basics of AI benchmarking and what researchers can trust LLMs for and what needs verification.
Choosing the right AI tool
There’s no single perfect AI tool. It’s far more important to first test any tool on the task you want it to perform. Claude may deliver faultless code for your labmate and rubbish to you. ChatGPT may extract data perfectly for your systematic review but may fail to debug code for your meta-analysis. Any AI tool improves your research workflow only if you know which tasks you should delegate to it, prompt it smartly, and check its output for hallucinations.
AI model comparison: ChatGPT vs Claude vs Gemini vs Perplexity
Now we look at the 4 most popular large language models (LLMs) both within and outside academia. Keep in mind that all 4 are general-purpose, designed for not just academia but also public and business use.
ChatGPT
The dominant player in the global market for generative AI assistants, ChatGPT is, however, currently losing market share to competitors. Nevertheless, it’s still a household word and is still the most used “raw” AI platform in the world (i.e., used without integration into another tool).
Useful features for academics include:
- Deep Research mode that can execute multi-step web searches. This is suitable if you want to explore a topic but isn’t a replacement for a literature search that’s meant for a literature review.
- ChatGPT Codex to write, manage and debug code using natural language prompts (i.e., no prior coding skill required).
- Data processing: researchers can upload data charts, CSV snippets, code, or experimental protocols to clean and interpret data.
Claude
Anthropic’s Claude currently holds around 17% of the general chatbot market share, but is much more popular than other AI models for business use (54% of the enterprise coding market). At the end of June 2026, Anthropic launched Claude Science, an AI workbench developed specifically for researchers. Key uses are
- Searches over 60 scientific databases (such as PubMed and bioRxiv)
- Installs and manages local Python and R environments and executes code
- Creates complex scientific visuals for 3D protein structures, chemical formulas, and genome browser tracks
Claude Science combines Claude’s AI models with tools for running Python, R, and shell code. It provides access to scientific databases and can save anything it produces (artifacts) along with the code and setup used to create them; this is essential for reproducibility in research. It also includes a background reviewer, which re-reads responses, saved artifacts, and the execution record and then checks whether the claims match what actually ran. Claude’s background reviewer can flag
- results that were reported as computed when nothing ran,
- values that contradict the file they came from,
- citations that do not support the claim, and
- DOIs that resolve to a different article.
Gemini
Google’s Gemini currently holds around 27-30% of the AI assistant and chatbot market share worldwide. Unlike ChatGPT and Claude, Gemini is not just a separate browser window you open but it’s also integrated in Google Workspace apps like Gmail, Docs, and Drive. Some of the features that make Gemini useful for researchers are
- Deep Research Agent: Plans, executes, and synthesizes complex, multi-step research tasks (note again that this is not an actual AI-assisted literature search that would be suitable for a literature review)
- Multi-Source Grounding: Gemini can combine data from the Internet/websites with documents that you upload, like PDFs and spreadsheets, and with external tools connected via Model Context Protocol (MCP) servers. This means that you can fetch up-to-date papers, preprint updates, or live statistical datasets and also cross-reference private lab notes or internal institutional databases with Internet sources.
- AI Co-Scientist: Co-Scientist can generate new, testable hypotheses and possible research directions that a researcher might not find on their own. It can turn a research question into a detailed research overview and suggest experimental protocols for testing the ideas.
Google tested Co-Scientist on problems involving drug repurposing, liver fibrosis, and antimicrobial resistance. Some of its suggestions were subsequently tested in laboratory experiments
Perplexity
Perplexity is somewhat small fry compared to the others, holding just Perplexity 2.5%- 4.3% of the global AI search and chatbot market share in 2026. It’s main selling proposition is that every key claim in an answer includes inline footnotes and clickable source links, which makes fact-checking and deep-diving fast and transparent.
- Academic focus mode: restricts your search to peer-reviewed articles, scholarly databases, and scientific journals instead of the entire web.
- Perplexity Deep Research can run multiple iterative web searches, analyze multiple documents, and compile structured reports.
Having said that, my opinion is that Perplexity lags behind the others in developing researcher-focused features and capabilities.
ChatGPT vs Claude for research
| Criterion | ChatGPT | Claude |
| Web and literature search | Stronger web browsing capabilities | Research mode that compiles multi-source reports with citations |
| Long documents | Limits vary by plan | Excels at reading multiple long-form documents and datasets |
| Data analysis | Built-in Python sandbox environment that runs, tests, and fixes code or creates charts directly in your chat. | Code execution and file creation for analysis. Uses Claude Artifacts to display interactive components, visual frameworks, or clean code structures cleanly alongside your text |
| Organization | Custom GPTs and Projects for reusable workflows | Projects that keep papers and instructions together across chats |
| Citation reliability | Can fabricate or misattribute references, so verify each one | Uses a more conservative approach to find citations but hallucination risk is not absent |
ChatGPT vs Gemini for research
| Capability | ChatGPT | Gemini |
| Web and literature search | Strong web browsing and a deep research mode that produces cited reports | Tight integration with Google Search, which helps surface recent sources |
| Long documents | Handles large uploads well, though context limits vary by plan | Known for very large context windows, useful for reading many papers at once |
| Data analysis | Built-in code execution for stats, charts, and cleaning data | Also runs code, with good Google Sheets integration |
| Works with | Custom GPTs, plugins, and a broad third-party app ecosystem | Works inside Docs, Drive, Gmail, and NotebookLM |
| Accuracy of citations | Can fabricate or misattribute references, so verify every one, including DOIs and quotes | Same risk |
Understanding AI model benchmarking: Basics of AI model performance comparison
AI benchmarking uses standardized tests and datasets to measure and compare how well artificial intelligence models perform on specific tasks.
Common Types of AI Benchmarks
- Language and Knowledge: Tests like Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) check broad world knowledge and problem-solving ksills.
- Math and Logic: Tests like Grade School Math 8K (GSM8K) check how good an LLM is at multi-step mathematical reasoning, like what you find in grade-school math word problems.
- Coding: Tests like HumanEval contain handwritten programming problems that check if an AI can write and fix computer code. The problems assess how good the AI is at language comprehension, basic math, string manipulation, and algorithmic problem-solving.
- Vision: Tests like ImageNet Large Scale Visual Recognition Challenge check how well an AI recognizes and classifies objects in pictures.
What Can Researchers Generally Trust AI For?
As the previous section shows, general-purpose LLMs are tested using general-purpose benchmarks. It’s very difficult to benchmark an AI tool for highly complex, niche, or emerging research topics, where there’s insufficient material to even create adequate training and benchmarking data, and evaluation requires specialized domain knowledge that only a small community of researchers possess. Here’s what researchers can and cannot trust to AI:
Relatively lower-risk uses
- Brainstorming keywords
- Generating research questions
- Explaining terminology
- Creating outlines
- Improving readability
- Suggesting ways to organize information
Medium-risk uses
- Summarizing papers
- Comparing theories
- Identifying themes
- Explaining statistical concepts
- Synthesizing information from documents
- Correcting language and proofreading
What Should You Verify in AI Output?
The following must never be copied directly from any LLM into your research paper. Always check them independently first.
- References and citations
- Numerical results
- Statistical interpretations
- Recommendations for patient care or clinical practice
- Claims about individual studies
- Research methods
- Journal policies
- Current guidelines and most recent advances
- Legal, ethical, or regulatory information
You can refer to our guide on how to check different types of AI output for hallucinations.
Importantly, AI-assisted editing or proofreading doesn’t guarantee that AI does not hallucinate or introduce errors. If you’re using an LLM to fix language errors in your paper, prompt it to focus only on grammatical and sentence construction errors and to not add or delete information. Run the before and after versions of the paper using MS Word’s Compare-Merge feature and cross-check every edit.


Comment