Understanding Editorial Decisions: Reject, Major Revision, Minor Revision, and Accept
When you receive a decision letter from a journal editor, your eyes automatically search for words like “Reject,” “Major Revision,” “Minor Revision,” and “Accept.”
But these letters are not merely notifications of acceptance or rejection; they are editorial decisions that assess the completeness of the research and guide you in your next steps. In this article, we will explain the significance of these four major decisions and how authors should respond to journals.
Who decides the fate of peer-reviewed manuscripts?
Rejection: Analyze the reason and prepare for the next submission
Major Revision: Thoroughly review the core of your research
Minor Revision: Correcting the details
Acceptance: Verification process
Four things to check before submitting the revised manuscript
Summary
Frequently asked questions (FAQs)
Who Decides the Fate of Peer-reviewed Manuscripts?
Manuscripts submitted to journals undergo an initial review by the editor to check the paper’s suitability to journal before an external peer review. While peer reviewers evaluate the originality of the research, the validity of the methods, the interpretation of results, and differentiation from existing studies, the final decision rests with the journal’s editor. Therefore, a single reviewer’s recommendation for “Accept” does not guarantee immediate publication. Neither does one reviewer’s recommendation to “Reject” lead to automatic rejection. The editor synthesizes the comments from all reviewers and issues a decision of rejection, significant revision, minor revision, or acceptance. The specific requirements outlined in the decision letter are more important than the label of the decision.
Rejection: Analyze the Reason and Prepare for the Next Submission
Simply put, a rejection is when a journal decides not to publish the submitted manuscript. However, there are different types of rejections.
A desk rejection is a decision made by an editor before the manuscript is sent for external review; it may occur when the manuscript does not align with the journal’s research scope or falls short of expectations regarding originality, academic contribution, or manuscript format.
On the other hand, a rejection after peer review is determined after examining the feedback from external reviewers. Reasons may be structural issues with the research design, insufficient data, discrepancies between claims and results, or a contribution that fails to meet the journal’s publication standards.
What you should do after rejection decision
If you receive a rejection, first identify the key reason in the decision letter.
- If the journal’s scope is the issue, select a more suitable journal
- If the methodology is the problem, supplement your analysis with supporting evidence
A standard final rejection differs from an invitation to submit a revised manuscript. Some journals may allow a new submission after significant revisions through options like “Reject and Resubmit” or “Open Reject.” Therefore, you must verify whether resubmission to the same journal is permitted by checking the details outlined in the decision letter and submission guidelines.
Tip: Usually, unless there is an explicit invitation, do not resubmit to the same journal. Instead, take the feedback positively and revise the manuscript to prepare it for submission to another journal.
Major Revision: Thoroughly Review the Core of Your Research
A major revision means that while the paper is likely to be published, significant modifications are required prior to the final decision. You may be asked to clarify the research question, explain the validity of experimental conditions, provide additional analysis, or reinterpret existing results. For example, if a reviewer highlights that it is difficult to validate the reason for reaching certain conclusions based on the summarized results due to the lack of a control group, simply revising the sentence is insufficient. You must add appropriate control experiments or analyses; otherwise, clearly state the limitations of the study and the scope of the conclusions.
What you should do after “major revision” decision
1. Start by categorizing the comments from editors and reviewers
2. Address criticisms affecting your research methods and key conclusions
3. Proceed with supplementing the literature and revising affected sections
4. Simultaneously, start drafting a response letter to reviewers to highlight the changes made in the revised manuscript
Remember, a “major revision” decision does not guarantee acceptance for publication. The revised version may be returned to the original reviewers or new ones, and if the revisions are insufficient, further revisions may be requested or a rejection decision may be issued. Therefore, address the key issues raised completely rather than rushing into a quick resubmission.
Minor Revision: Correcting the Details
A minor revision request signifies that the overall direction or main conclusions of the research are generally acceptable, but relatively limited modifications are required before final acceptance. This may include correcting typos, standardizing terminology, supplementing references, adding figure descriptions, clarifying statistical figures, or requesting explanations for specific sentences.
What you should do after “minor revision” decision
1. Classify the comments based on the effort required for each change
2. Fix the basic changes first and then proceed to deeper changes
3. Make the corrections in the manuscript section-wise
4. Confirm whether the corrections made in the manuscript aligns with your response to each reviewer’s comment
5. If a suggestion was not incorporated, provide a polite and specific explanation for the same
The editor may review the revised submission to either accept the manuscript or request further review. Therefore, a “minor revision” decision also does not guarantee acceptance.
Acceptance: Verification Process
“Accept” means that the editor has decided to publish the paper. This decision is very rare in the first round of evaluation, and it does not mean that the paper will be immediately published.
Following acceptance, depending on the publisher, the process may continue with
- proofreading,
- review of affiliation and author information,
- processing of publication consent forms,
- selection of publication type (e.g., open access or paywalled), and
- finalizing the article processing charges (APCs).
At this stage, proofreading primarily involves correcting typesetting errors and does not require addition of new data or conclusions. Once the final verification is complete, the journal proceeds to publish your paper.
Four Things to Check Before Submitting the Revised Manuscript
- First, respond to all comments. Drafting an effective response letter or rebuttal letter is key. Make sure that all reviewers’ comments are numbered properly to ease the review of resubmitted paper. The revisions made in the manuscript must synchronize with your responses. Provide clarity on all revisions, explain why you disagree with certain comments, and justify your reasons for not modifying content with sufficient evidence.
- Second, specify the location of the modification. Rather than a short answer like “We have made the requested change,” add descriptions like “We have added a repeated measurement condition to Section 2.3 in the Methodology.” Better yet, include line numbers and page numbers to direct the reviewers to the correct location in the manuscript.
- Third, check the consistency of the revisions. If you have corrected the reported findings in the main text, the same revisions must be reflected in the abstract, tables, figures, and conclusion. Also, review the references and supplementary materials and make corresponding changes if needed.
- Fourth, check the revision period (or deadline). Deadlines vary journal to journal and may differ even within the same journal depending on whether it is a major or minor revision. If meeting the deadline is difficult due to additional experiments, request an extension.
Summary
| Journal decisions | Action points for authors |
| Reject | Reasons for rejection and whether resubmission is allowed |
| Major revision | Key revision requests and the possibility of re-evaluation |
| Minor revision | Revision items and editorial board verification process |
| Accept | Final manuscript and publication procedures |
Rejection can be an opportunity to reorganize your research, while major and minor revisions are chances to advance your paper. Be sure to read the decision letter calmly and remain objective when responding to the requested revisions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. How long does it usually take for journals to review papers?
Initial review may take 2 to 3 weeks, depending on the submission volume to the journal. If the paper is sent for peer review, it may take anywhere from a few weeks to several months depending on the availability of reviewers. Since there are significant variations depending on the field and journal operational methods, check the review time guidelines on the journal’s website.
Q2. What is the revision period or deadline for submitting the revised manuscript?
There is no fixed deadline that’s common for all journals. Extensions may range from 1 to 4 weeks for minor revisions. In the case of major revisions, the deadline could be 1 to 2 months. Some journals even set the same deadline to major and minor revisions. Depending on the submission date and journal guidelines, request an extension in advance if necessary.
Q3. Can I resubmit a rejected paper to the same journal?
You cannot resubmit the original manuscript as is following a standard rejection decision. However, there is an exception if the journal explicitly permits new submission after significant revisions. Check the reason for desk rejection before appealing the decision and resubmit only if you receive a positive response from the journal.
Q4. How long does it take for an accepted paper to be published?
It varies depending on subsequent tasks such as proofreading, typesetting, and publishing contracts. An online preview may take place first and the official volume and issue may be assigned later. Once your manuscript is accepted, stay in touch with the publication team to determine the publishing schedule.
Q5. What is the difference between a desk rejection and a rejection after peer review?
Desk rejection is a decision made by the editor prior to external peer review, with journal suitability or basic requirements being the primary factors influencing the decision. Rejection after peer review is a decision made by the journal editor after reviewing evaluations and comments by external experts.
Q6. Is publication guaranteed if I receive a major revision decision?
No. While the potential of the research has been acknowledged, peer reviewers re-evaluate the paper to determine if the key issues have been resolved after you resubmit. If additional experiments, analyses, or responses you provided are insufficient, the paper may be rejected or the editor may request further revisions.
Q7. Is it okay if I do not agree with the peer reviewers’ comments?
It is completely alright to disagree, but how you disagree matters more! Do not dismiss the opinion rudely. Instead, provide a polite explanation based on relevant data, literature, or the scope of the research and include an evidence-backed reason for disagreeing with the reviewer’s comment. In your response letter, explain why the correction was not made and clarify whether any alternative modifications were made in the manuscript.
Disclaimer: This article was originally authored in Korean and has been translated to English.

