Researcher Q&A

Responding to Peer Reviewers

Filter by a different topic

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

arrow Latest

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

Q: How do I reply to the referees' comments after a second revision?

Detailed question-I will be resubmitting my manuscript after a second revision. How do I proceed and how do I reply to the editor and reviewers?

1 Answer

Hello Lamia – Welcome back to the forum! Your question comes at such an apt time – during Peer Review Week 2020…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What is the difference between 'reviewing a study' and 'commenting on a study'?

Detailed question-I have received some comments on a review article from the editor of a journal. He asked me to comment on a few studies that I forgot to review. I would like to ask what…
  • Asked on September 21, 2020

2 Answers

You are on the right track. Comments such as “it was a good study, a bad study, or whatever” is…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Do we have to cite the reviewer-suggested article?

Detailed question-We submitted an article to a journal. After two months, we received the reviewers’ comments to revise the article. One of the reviewers asked us to add two references in…
  • Asked on August 13, 2020

1 Answer

This is a fairly common occurrence. It’s called coercive citation, with the implications your…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Can I revise some parts of a manuscript even if they have not been requested by the reviewer?

Detailed question-I am presently revising my manuscript as per peer review comments. During the first submission, a major revision was required. So, I added figures and tables and…
  • Asked on August 11, 2020

1 Answer

One part of your query is not clear. It’s not clear what the reviewer has asked you to remove in the second round: some…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How do I write a summary letter?

Detailed question-What is the perfect method of writing point-by-point answers to comments by reviewers?
  • Asked on July 25, 2020

1 Answer

Firstly, it’s great to know that you are at the revisions stage, which means that your manuscript is one step closer to publication. :-) Also, going by your…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Is there any higher organization to make a complaint for a malicious peer review?

Detailed question-If I encounter a malicious peer review, can I make a complaint to any higher organization?
  • Asked on July 17, 2020

1 Answer

Your question is so pithy and pointed, we shall also get to the response straight away.

Unfortunately, no, there isn't any higher organization in research…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How do I best respond to positive feedback from reviewers?

Detailed question-I have received feedback from peer reviewers on an article submitted, but some of the comments are positive! A number of the comments agree with points made in the…

1 Answer

Hello Annie – Welcome to the forum! And this time, we respond with a bit more seriousness. :-)

Straight away, what a great position to be in! I don’t think…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Are there any tips on how to respond to positive feedback from peer reviewers?

Detailed question-I have received feedback from peer review, and amongst the feedback, are statements where the reviewers have agreed with points we have made or commended the argument. I…
  • Asked on July 15, 2020

1 Answer

LOL! You seem to have the opposite ‘problem’ of that faced by most authors. :-) Which is why, although you seem to have posted the same query twice, and we…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How should I reply to a reviewer comment stating that the sample size is small?

Detailed question-The reviewer asked why the sample size is small or why I did not include some other samples, which is quite true, in fact. How should I reply to these questions in a…
  • Asked on July 13, 2020

1 Answer

It’s interesting that you too sense that the sample size is too small. So, the reviewer’s comments do seem valid. In that case, here are the possible ways in which…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Can you help me understand this comment on my review article that received a minor revision?

Detailed question-My review article received a minor revision with one of the comments as follows: “The advantages, disadvantages, and synergy of each strategy need to be compared with [a…

1 Answer

This seems to be a systematic review. However, it’s not clear if it’s a qualitative review or a…

Answer
Follow this Question