Researcher Q&A

Responding to Peer Reviewers

Filter by a different topic

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

arrow Latest

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

New Question Added

Q: How to respond to reviewer comments asking for major revisions?

Detailed question-Our manuscript has received major revisions. We have done whatever the reviewers have asked. How to respond to the comments?

1 Answer

You should always provide point-by-point responses to the reviewer comments in addition to incorporating the reviewers'…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How to respond to repeat comments from a reviewer which I've already incorporated in my revised document?

Detailed question-I've got a minor revision from one journal after reject and resubmit. The comments of one reviewer are repeated word for word; I think he/she has not seen my responses…

1 Answer

Firstly, as you have received only a minor revision after an earlier status of “reject and resubmit,” good show on that! About the repeat comments, you may be right…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How to handle critical feedback from research supervisors?

Detailed question-What is the advice for students to handle critical feedback from supervisors? As one delves into the field of research, it is axiomatic that one is still a novice. On…

1 Answer

As you have rightly noted, feedback can hit hard, especially when you are relatively new to the…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How should I reply if a reviewer says my sample size is small?

Detailed question-I submitted a paper regarding a sleep experiment, and one of the reviewers pointed out that sample size is not big enough. I have checked other papers which handle sleep…
  • Asked on August 12, 2019

1 Answer

If you are determined that your sample size is sufficient, you can write back to the journal explaining your point of view. It is not…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Is it all right for an author to ask the reviewers questions for clarifications?

Detailed question-How should the editor deal with such situations?

1 Answer

It is alright for authors to ask the reviewers for clarifications regarding their comments. Sometimes reviewers’ comments may not be very…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How should I respond to a comment where the reviewer has failed to notice some information?

Detailed question-I received the result of peer review. The comment says “the information of research sample (specifically, the stage of the patients who participated the clinical…
  • Asked on July 26, 2019

1 Answer

It is alright to disagree with a reviewer's comment if you feel that your idea is justified. You can politely explain your perspective to…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How to respond to a reviewer comment that we cannot address?

Detailed question-I submitted a paper to a journal, and after 5 months the editor sent an email:"I have decided that your manuscript can be accepted for publication after you have carried…
  • Asked on April 20, 2019

1 Answer

Since you are so close to publication, it would be really great if you could come up with one or two questions even if you are not very…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Can I raise an objection to the Editor about the additional revisions suggested in the second round of review?

Detailed question-In the second round of review, I was required to revise several points which were not pointed out in the first round of review. It was obviously possible to point them…
  • Asked on January 11, 2019

1 Answer

In most cases, the revised submission is sent to the same reviewers who reviewed the manuscript the first time. However, sometimes, the revised paper may be assigned…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How should I respond to a reviewer's comment regarding selection bias?

Detailed question-I have received a reviewer's comment that states: "Only 750 subjects out of 23,188 subjects remained. Why did so few people answer the questions? There may be a huge…
  • Asked on January 6, 2019

1 Answer

A response to any methodological comment by the reviewer should be considered serious and responded with adequate clarity. Considering…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Should I revise the manuscript and resubmit it to the same journal?

Detailed question-My manuscript was recently rejected, and resubmission was suggested with the message below. From this message, I feel a resubmission to this journal would lead to a good…
  • Asked on December 21, 2018

1 Answer

As you have correctly observed, it does seem from the editor's message that the journal would be interested in publishing your paper…

Answer
Follow this Question