Your Research. Your Life. Your Story.

A magnetic community of researchers bound by their stories

Why being vulnerable with your advisors is the right thing to do

Reading time
6 mins
Why being vulnerable with your advisors is the right thing to do

I am struggling. And, until a few days ago, the fact that I was struggling – especially that I was visibly struggling – was making me struggle that much more. It was a vicious cycle that I found myself in, until I finally broke.

“The thing about a spiral is, if you follow inward, it never actually ends. It just keeps tightening, infinitely.” – John Green, Turtles All the Way Down

I decided to entirely restructure my thesis three days before my draft was due. Right move, wrong timing. I realized the day before that it would be physically impossible for me to get a draft that I was proud of by the deadline, so I emailed my advisors asking for an extension. Just an extra four days. I heard back from two of them that that was fine, and assumed the others would be fine as well.

The universe had other plans. Waking up the next day, I was sick with the flu, and my partner’s family was in town for the first and only time during our grad school experience. I tried to manage my declining health, work on my thesis, and entertain a group of people that I desperately wanted to impress. Spoiler alert: it did not go well. I got sicker, my thesis did not get better (I would argue that by rushing to get it done, I sacrificed the quality of my work, so it actually got worse for a short period), and it became obvious to everyone that I was very ill. I had to take a day and sleep it off.

Two days before my next deadline, I had still not made substantial progress on my thesis. I began to panic.

Why can’t you just write it down? You’ve been working on this for a year. Just make the damn argument.

But I physically couldn’t. Stress had colored my brain, until all I could think about was the fact that I was late and not making any progress.

You’re going to miss another deadline. You won’t get good recommendation letters. Your thesis is sh*t. You won’t get into PhD programs. Drop out now and join the circus.

The day before my self-imposed deadline comes along, and I’m in no better shape than I was when the original deadline passed. I decide that I have to go to class, even though I am only auditing and have not read the material, because I’d already missed class once that week and wanted to impress the professor. I do not hear a word of the lecture, do not participate in the group discussion. All I can think about are the seconds going by, seconds that I am not using to write.

I feel a panic attack coming on. Leave to go to the bathroom. Text my partner, “I am not doing well,” after a week of pretending everything is going fine. After all, he was able to make the first deadline. I email my advisor. Here are my exact words:

“Would you by chance have time to meet today? I wouldn’t say it’s an emergency, but I would really appreciate it.”

My partner responds. He’s been stressed too, and feeling unconfident in his work. We make a plan to help each other later in the evening.

My advisor responds: “Come to my office at 3.”

I breathe. Manage to regain control of the panic attack (thanks to years of counselling; I’m not a magician). Return to class where I am still unable to pay attention.

I walk over to my advisor’s office. I am twenty minutes early, but his door is open. He invites me in and I close the door.

Immediately, I begin bawling. I tell him what has been going on, how I have been spiralling, and how it’s gotten so bad that I’ve been questioning my ability as a philosopher.

I realize that it wasn’t the thesis, or even the deadline that was causing such an impenetrable mental block. It was that I was so worried about the fact that I was late, that my thesis wasn’t up to my standards, and I was worried that someone else would realize that I’m struggling. In my mind, I had connected the fact that I was struggling with the belief that I wasn’t good enough or cut out for academia. Saying it out loud made me realize how wrong that sounded.

I am very lucky to have sympathetic advisors. The story may have gone differently, if I didn’t. But my advisor calmed me down, explained that others were also in my situation, and that the fact that I was late and that my draft was a work in progress, did not disappoint him. He assured me that he had seen me do good work, or else I would not be doing as well in the program, and that I have impressed the entire department with both my philosophical talent and commitment to the program. He told me to send him what I have, and would help me improve it.

I leave his office feeling better. I email my other advisors, explaining that I have been struggling and that this draft is not a reflection of my best work. I feel like I’ve accomplished something.

Following the meeting, I still have missed a deadline. I still do not have a completed draft that I am proud of.

But I no longer feel like the fact that I am struggling is a reflection of my academic ability, or an indication that I lack the tenacity needed to survive in academia.

I am still struggling, but I am no longer spiralling.

“Spirals grow infinitely smaller the farther you follow them inward, but they also grow infinitely larger the farther you follow them out.” – John Green, Turtles All the Way Down

PhDoing Life is a Philosophy graduate student. This story was published on September 9, 2018, on the blog, PhDoing Life (available here), and has been republished here with permission.

Be the first to clap

for this article

Published on: May 21, 2019

Interested primarily in normative ethics and social philosophy
See more from PhDoing Life


You're looking to give wings to your academic career and publication journey. We like that!

Why don't we give you complete access! Create a free account and get unlimited access to all resources & a vibrant researcher community.

One click sign-in with your social accounts

1536 visitors saw this today and 1210 signed up.