Researcher Q&A

Dealing with Rejection

Filter by a different topic

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

arrow Latest

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

New Question Added

Q: What should I do after my paper was ignored by Scientific Reports?

Detailed question-On January 30, I submitted my article to Scientific Reports to be considered in a special collection. I submitted it through the new system, where they state that within…

1 Answer

Firstly, a part toward the end of your question was incomplete. So, we have edited it based on…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Should I resubmit to the same journal a manuscript they rejected but suggested for modification?

Detailed question-My paper was rejected before review. However, the reviewer asked me to modify it, mentioning that he would be interested in evaluating it after the modification. So,…

1 Answer

I see your manuscript has received a desk rejection. However, even while rejecting it, the Associate Editor (AE) seems to see some…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How to deal with a rejection based on an unfair review?

Detailed question-My manuscript was rejected based on one of three reviews. Two reviews were really positive, stating that the study makes an important contribution to the field. The…

1 Answer

As an author, it always hurts when your paper is rejected. Most authors feel that their…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Is there a service for advanced review and editing for a manuscript?

Detailed question-My manuscript in Japanese was rejected. Is there any service that checks the rejected manuscript and the review comments and makes necessary editing work for the…

1 Answer

Editage offers resubmission support as part of its publication support services. 

If your paper has received reviewer comments, our publication experts will…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Should I write a thank you note for a rejection letter from the editor?

Detailed question-My article has been rejected by a journal on the ground that the work didn’t fit the journal’s purview and readership. The editor suggested to submitting the manuscript…
  • Asked on August 29, 2018

2 Answers

This is a template message. The massage has not been written by the editor. If you reply, the message will be read by the managing editor (but not the editor in chief)…
Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Should I submit my paper to an affiliate open access journal after rejection?

Detailed question-My manuscript was rejected by a journal after review, but the reviewer’s comment was helpful and recommended me the submission to its affiliate open journal. The impact…
  • Asked on October 20, 2017

1 Answer

Since the reviewer has recommended submission to the affiliate journal, it is probably more suitable for your paper in terms of scope,…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What is the process for a rejected manuscript that has been revised and resubmitted?

Detailed question-Hi all, Recently I received an email from the editor of a relatively high-rank journal that my manuscript was rejected according to the associate editor comments, but he…

1 Answer

Usually, for a manuscript that is rejected without peer review, it is treated as a completely new submission. Of course, the editor will…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How can I improve my manuscript's chances that has been rejected by four journals?

Detailed question-I have sent my manuscript to four different journals in five years. In each journal, I have made the majority of changes suggested by the reviewers. Every time I sent…
  • Asked on May 8, 2017

1 Answer

Ideally, the peer review process should be free of bias. Authors from many non-English speaking countries get their papers published in…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: My article got rejected after the journal editor changed. What should I do?

Detailed question-My article was submitted to a journal last year and has undergone three rounds of reviews. For the first round, I recieved a major revision and for the next two rounds,…

1 Answer

You have mentioned that the new editor said it would be "fine" if it was a minor revision. What exactly do you mean by that? Did the…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Can I appeal against the rejection of my paper?

Detailed question-After submitting my paper on 30thApr 2015, I have received the final result - rejection - on 2nd May 2016, more than one year later. On going through the decision letter…
  • Asked on May 17, 2016

1 Answer

While authors have the freedom to appeal against the editorial decision, the final decision is generally not changed. Most authors feel…

Answer
Follow this Question