This content belongs to the Journal Submission Stage

The journal submission stage can be challenging. Subscribe & improve your manuscript’s chances of acceptance with the help of guidelines and tips shared by our publication experts.

Q&A: Can I submit two papers on very similar topics to the same journal?

I'm currently in the process of submitting two different papers. The two papers are on the same topic but are slightly different. I am the corresponding author for both although the first authors are different in each case. However, I feel like this is not right and it can be a disadvantage. In this case, would it be better to submit my papers to two different journals or can they be submitted to the same journal? 

1 Answer

Publishing two papers on the same or a very similar topic can be considered unethical unless the two studies are completely different in content and focus. If the two papers have very similar or overalapping content, they might be considered duplicate submission or salami slicing.

Duplicate submission refers to the practice of submitting two very similar papers to two journals and trying to publish them as two papers when one paper is sufficient.  Salami slicing refers to the practice of partitioning a large study that could have been reported in a single research article into smaller published articles. A set of papers are referred to as salami publications when more than one paper covers the same data, methods, and research question. Both of these are considered unethical and the journal can take action against you if detected.

Therefore, you should be very careful about publishing two papers on the same topic. The data and methods section can be similar, but you have to make sure that you have a new research question and that all the other sections of the paper - the literature review, discussion, analysis of the findings - are completely different. If you feel that the two papers are very similar or have a lot of overlapping content, then it would be better to not publish the second paper at all or publish it as a second part or a follow-up study. You can send a pre-submission inquiry to the editor, giving a short summary of both the papers and asking if they can be published as two separate studies or if the second one can be published as follow up of the previous study.

Recommended reading:

What can be the reason behind two papers by the same author having similar content?

Is it ethical to submit a paper to two or more journals simultaneously?

Is publishing the same paper in different languages duplication?

 


This content belongs to the Journal Submission Stage

The journal submission stage can be challenging. Subscribe & improve your manuscript’s chances of acceptance with the help of guidelines and tips shared by our publication experts.