Researcher Q&A

Reasons for Rejection

Filter by a different topic

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

arrow Latest

Popular

Latest

Unanswered

Q: How should I interpret the rejection email notification from the journal editor?

Detailed question-I received a rejection notification by email that includes the following sentence: “While your work is well conceived and presented, we feel it is only a lower priority…
  • Asked on March 29, 2021

1 Answer

Sorry to know that your manuscript was rejected. This seems to be a desk rejection, because the responses for these are…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What should I do to identify a suitable journal to take my manuscript toward acceptance?

Detailed question-I have submitted my manuscript several times, and but it has been rejected each time. So, I am [still] looking for a journal. However, I’m not sure how to identify and…
  • Asked on March 12, 2021

1 Answer

Sorry to hear that your manuscript has been rejected so far. Actually, there are many reasons why a manuscript may be…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What does the With Editor status mean for an Elsevier journal after being with the Managing Editor (ME)?

Detailed question-I submitted a paper to an Elsevier journal. They sent me a mail stating that it is with the ME. Recently, I received another mail stating that my paper is now with the…
  • Asked on February 1, 2021

7 Answers

The With Editor status may refer to the handling editor for your paper, known as either the…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What might be the outcome for my manuscript if I submitted it without language editing?

Detailed question-I submitted a manuscript that has not been edited for language because I was about to miss the deadline for a special issue of the journal. What will the editor do in…
  • Asked on January 6, 2021

1 Answer

You have two broad queries. One, of course, is around whether your manuscript will proceed to…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Why would a journal not give the author the reviews for a rejected paper?

Detailed question-My paper was sent for review six weeks ago, after being acknowledged as submitted four weeks after submission. However, no reviews were attached. This seems very strange…
  • Asked on December 16, 2020

1 Answer

Firstly, sorry to know your paper was rejected. A rejection is disappointing to begin with, and…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Will my manuscript be rejected if a word is missing in the revised version?

Detailed question-I have found a word missing in a sentence after submitting the revision. Will it lead to rejection of the manuscript?
  • Asked on December 1, 2020

1 Answer

It’s great that you are looking into your manuscript even after sending the revised version. It…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Why do some editors reject papers without stating the reasons for the rejection?

Detailed question-We know that rejection of research papers is very common in academic publishing, but what really bothers authors is when their papers get rejected without knowing the…

1 Answer

Hello Amir – Welcome to the forum! And straight off, we can understand your anguish. :-(

The thing is, there are always some ‘bad seeds,’ as they say. Most…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: What are the indicators of acceptance in highly trusted journals, and what does 'Awaiting reviewer scores' mean?

Detailed question-I have two questions.What are the indicators of acceptance of scientific papers in highly trusted journals (Q1-4)?Could you also tell me what does 'Awaiting reviewer…

1 Answer

Hello Rasha – Welcome to the forum!

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: How can I address the journal's comment on the originality of my paper?

Detailed question-I received a reply on originality from the journal, how shall I respond and what I should do next?Although I appreciate the scientific efforts represented by this work,…
  • Asked on April 22, 2019

1 Answer

The response letter from the journal indicates that your paper was rejected since the automated plagiarism check at the journal end detected a high percentage of…

Answer
Follow this Question

Q: Is it ethical for a reviewer to recommend adding a co-author to a manuscript?

Detailed question-Question description: Upon being reviewed by an Elsevier journal, the manuscript received the following comments:The first reviewer has recommended acceptance after…

1 Answer

This is indeed an interesting recommendation by the reviewer. Adding the geochemist and geochronologist as co-authors would mean that they…

Answer
Follow this Question