Skip to main content

Mega Nav

Q&A Forum
Conducting Research
- Conducting Research (Stage 1)
Manuscript Writing
- Manuscript Writing (Stage 2)
  - Academic Writing
  - Research Paper Structure
Journal Selection & Submission
- Journal Selection (Stage 3)
  - Choosing a Journal
  - Publication models
- Journal Submission (Stage 4)
  - Manuscript Submission
Awaiting Decision
Post Publication
- Post Journal Publication (Stage 8)
Community & More

Researcher Q&A

Get all your questions on research writing and publishing answered by researchers and publication experts!

Top Q&A Topics

Manuscript Status

Submission Process

Planning to Write

Journal Selection Tips

Statement of the Problem

Research Ethics

Authorship in Research

Study Background & Introduction

Title, Abstract & keywords

Queries to the Editor

Other Content Types

Infographics & Downloadables

Courses & Handbooks

Webinars & Workshops

Hi ,

What is your academic question today?

Journal Rejection

Filter by a different topic

Latest

Q: How to deal with a rejection based on an unfair review?

Detailed question-My manuscript was rejected based on one of three reviews. Two reviews were really positive, stating that the study makes an important contribution to the field. The…

Asked by Elisabeth Eppard on August 16, 2019

1 Answer

As an author, it always hurts when your paper is rejected. Most authors feel that their…

Follow this Question

Q: How can I address the journal's comment on the originality of my paper?

Detailed question-I received a reply on originality from the journal, how shall I respond and what I should do next?Although I appreciate the scientific efforts represented by this work,…

Asked on April 22, 2019

1 Answer

The response letter from the journal indicates that your paper was rejected since the automated plagiarism check at the journal end detected a high percentage of…

Follow this Question

Q: Is there a service for advanced review and editing for a manuscript?

Detailed question-My manuscript in Japanese was rejected. Is there any service that checks the rejected manuscript and the review comments and makes necessary editing work for the…

Asked by Akihiro Aoyama on March 1, 2019

1 Answer

Editage offers resubmission support as part of its publication support services.

If your paper has received reviewer comments, our publication experts will…

Follow this Question

Q: Is it ethical for a reviewer to recommend adding a co-author to a manuscript?

Detailed question-Question description: Upon being reviewed by an Elsevier journal, the manuscript received the following comments:The first reviewer has recommended acceptance after…

Asked by Nusret Nurlu on September 17, 2018

1 Answer

This is indeed an interesting recommendation by the reviewer. Adding the geochemist and geochronologist as co-authors would mean that they…

Follow this Question

Q: Should I write a thank you note for a rejection letter from the editor?

Detailed question-My article has been rejected by a journal on the ground that the work didn’t fit the journal’s purview and readership. The editor suggested to submitting the manuscript…

Asked on August 29, 2018

2 Answers

This is a template message. The massage has not been written by the editor. If you reply, the message will be read by the managing editor (but not the editor in chief)…

Follow this Question

Q: My paper was rejected even though the reviews were favorable. What are my options?

Detailed question-It is very surprising that we had a manuscript rejected based on priority issues despite the fact that reviewers' comments are very positive with one of them declaring…

Asked by Ahmed Bendary on August 9, 2018

1 Answer

I agree with you that rejection due to issues with publication priority should ideally be done at the initial…

Follow this Question

Q: Can a short peer review process indicate manuscript rejection?

Detailed question-I had submitted a manuscript to a journal. First day, it showed "With editor," then after one day, it showed "Under review." After that, within one day it…

Asked by Misty Das on March 24, 2018

1 Answer

If the status changed to "Ready for Decision" within a day, it is indeed an unusually quick review. Even rapid…

Follow this Question

Q: Why do journals take too long to decide whether the research is appropriate and convey rejection?

Detailed question-I submitted a manuscript on 25th March 2017 to a journal indexed in Web of Science and it has an impact factor. Since May 2017, the status of my manuscript was reviewers…

Asked by Rasha Ahmed on March 3, 2018

1 Answer

Most of the journals take up to four weeks for the peer review process. This time varies across different journals…

Follow this Question

Q: Will my paper be rejected if I cannot suggest peer reviewers?

Detailed question-The structure of the cover letter of my journal demands a list of the colleagues who have checked my article. But I don't have any such colleagues.

Asked by Alexsandr Shcheblykin on December 12, 2017

4 Answers

Follow this Question

Q: Should I submit my paper to an affiliate open access journal after rejection?

Detailed question-My manuscript was rejected by a journal after review, but the reviewer’s comment was helpful and recommended me the submission to its affiliate open journal. The impact…

Asked on October 20, 2017

1 Answer

Since the reviewer has recommended submission to the affiliate journal, it is probably more suitable for your paper in terms of scope,…

Follow this Question

Pagination

Current page 1
Page 2
Page 3
Page 4
Next page
Last page

Filter by a topic

or

Select all topics

Conducting Research
Securing Research Funding
Funding Sources
Grant Application
Research Data Management
Data Storage & Management
Data Analysis
Publication Planning
Authorship in Research
Literature Search
Statement of the Problem
Planning to Write
Research Ethics

Manuscript Writing
Academic Writing
Grammar & Language
Style & Format
Plagiarism in Research
Research Paper Structure
Title, Abstract & keywords
Study Background & Introduction
Methods
Results & Discussion
Tables & Figures
References & Acknowledgements
Publication Support Services

Journal Selection
Choosing a Journal
Journal Selection Tips
Understanding the Impact Factor
Presubmission Inquiry
Publication Models
Open Access & Subscription Models
Rapid Publication
Avoiding Predatory Publishers

Journal Submission
Manuscript Submission
Submission Process
Ethical Declarations
Duplicate Submission

Manuscript Tracking
Tracking Your Submission
Manuscript Status
Queries to the Editor
Manuscript Withdrawal

Peer Review
Responding to Reviewer Comments
Basics of Peer Review
Responding to Peer Reviewers

Manuscript Rejection
Journal Rejection
Reasons for Rejection
Dealing with Rejection

Post Journal Publication
Research Retractions
Reasons for Retraction
Dealing with Retraction
Science Communication
Public Engagement
Plain Language Summaries
Video & Graphical Abstracts
Promoting your Research
Trending Research
Career Advancement
Showcasing Research Impact
Networking Online & Offline
Career Advice for Researchers

Community
Industry Opinion
Researchers and Their Stories
Resources for Editors & Reviewers

News & Updates
Scholarly Publishing Trends
Industry News
Industry Trends
Around the Web
Good Reads
Our Publication Showcase
Books & Tools

Help authors by answering these questions

how to write need for the study for this question?

can you give me an example of statement of the problem from an actual proposal

Did the tests fully cover the various usage scenarios of the system?

View all unanswered Q&As

View Forum Guidelines

Explore your Publication Stages >

About Editage Insights

Editage Insights offers a wealth of free academic research and publishing resources and is a one-stop guide for authors and others involved in scholarly publishing. Our original resources for authors and journals will help you become an expert in academic publishing. Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more.

Become a Member

Contribute as a Guest

Our Terms of Use

Subscribe

Read Editage Insights in your favorite RSS Reader.

Follow us on social platforms

Editage Insights Global Sites

Japanese – エディテージ・インサイト

Simplified Chinese – 意得辑专家视点

Korean - 에디티지 인사이트

Editage

About Editage
Contact Editage
News
Payment Options
Prices for Editing
Terms of Use

Publication Support Services

Artwork Preparation
Journal Selection
Journal Submission
Plagiarism Check
Publication Support Packs
Rapid Technical Review
Resubmission Support

Quality

Confidentiality
Delivery Guarantee
Publication Ethics
Quality Assurance
Testimonials

Editing Services

Advanced Editing
English Editing Services
Post-Editing Services
Premium Editing Plus
Premium Editing

Our Expertise

Business and Economics
Life Sciences
Medical Sciences
Physical Sciences
Social Sciences

Full disclosure: Editage Insights is a product of Editage, a global provider of world-class scientific communication solutions. Editage Insights is funded by Editage and endorses services provided by Editage but is editorially independent.

English Editing - Editage.com | 英文校正 – Editage.jp | 원어민영문교정 – Editage.co.kr | SCI英文论文发表 – Editage.cn | publicação de artigos – Editage.com.br | 編輯英文 – Editage.com.tw | Terms of Use for English Editing Services

2002— Cactus Communications. All Rights Reserved.

Icons made by various authors from www.flaticon.com

Trending Searches

Statement of the problem
Manuscript status
Background of study
Proposal writing
Publication courses
Rationale of the study
Methodology
Review paper
Literature review
Hypothesis
Under "Editor Evaluation"
Conclusion

Recent Searches

Cover letter
Responding to reviewer comments
Predatory publishers
Research objectives
Grant proposal
Open access
Plagiarism in research
Journal selection tips
Abstract
Difference between thesis and journal article
"Reject and Resubmit" status
Scope and limitations
Citations